Leadership and influence
What Happens When the Leader Speaks First?
When a leader shares a preference early, what happens to the options a team considers? Two studies offer facilitators a way to think about when to invite alternatives.
Imagine a team deciding which project deserves its limited time. Before anyone has discussed the options, the manager says, "I think we should focus on improving onboarding."
It's a reasonable suggestion. People begin talking about what better onboarding would involve, how long it might take, and whether it would make a difference. Nobody has been told to agree. Yet the conversation is already about one particular solution.
The manager could have started with a fact everyone needed: "We have six weeks." That gives the team a way to assess its options. Opening with a preferred project can send the team straight into working out how to do it. What else might they have considered if they had heard the deadline first?
The same problems, two ways to begin
In 1991, researchers Lance Anderson and William Balzer worked with 19 teams responsible for university student housing. The teams were asked to solve two problems typical of residence-hall work. 1
The teams were randomly assigned to two conditions. In one, leaders stated their opinions as soon as a problem was presented. In the other, leaders held back until the group had spent some time discussing it. 1
What changed when the leader waited?
Teams whose leaders waited came up with more possible solutions. The alternatives were also rated as more feasible and more likely to be adopted. The study measured the options these 19 teams generated and how those options were rated. It did not track which solutions teams eventually put into practice. 1
When a first suggestion reflects the discussion
Anderson and Balzer counted the alternatives teams generated. In 1992, Suzanne Weisband asked a different question: how closely did a group member's first proposal match the group's final choice? A proposal made at the very start showed no clear advantage. After some discussion, the first proposal was closer to the final decision than the average of members' starting preferences. Someone who has heard the group talk may be able to suggest an option the group already leans toward. 2
Give the group a chance to see its options
Return to the team choosing its next project. The manager suggests improving onboarding, and the conversation immediately turns to making that idea work.
A facilitator could invite the group to name other options before it spends more time on onboarding. Someone might suggest reducing customer support delays or fixing a problem with internal approvals. The team can compare those projects with onboarding and ask which would make the best use of its six weeks. Inviting alternatives in this way is a practical suggestion inspired by the studies.
What did we consider before we agreed?
In Protocol15, the shared ranking records where the team landed. During the debrief, the facilitator can ask which suggestion the team built on first and what other approaches it considered.
When there is still time to weigh the options, ask:
"Before we decide, what else should we seriously consider?"
Research references
- Anderson, Lance E., and William K. Balzer. (1991). "The Effects of Timing of Leaders' Opinions on Problem-Solving Groups: A Field Experiment." Group & Organization Studies, 16(1), 86-101. DOI: 10.1177/105960119101600106
- Weisband, Suzanne P. (1992). "Group Discussion and First Advocacy Effects in Computer-Mediated and Face-to-Face Decision Making Groups." Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 53(3), 352-380. DOI: 10.1016/0749-5978(92)90070-N