Skip to content

Team pacing

Why Teams Change Direction Halfway Through a Task

Why do teams change their approach as a deadline gets closer? Research on team pacing offers a useful distinction between changing how people work and simply working faster.

Four bank executives had 34 days to design a new type of account. By their third meeting, halfway through the assignment, they still had not decided exactly what they would offer.

The first two meetings had been spent working through federal regulations, listing questions, and exploring possible features. There was plenty to discuss, but the discussion kept producing more questions.

At the start of the third meeting, one member worried that they might reach the deadline without finishing. The group changed its approach. Two staff experts joined the discussion to help ensure the proposed account would work with the bank's computer systems. Over the next two hours, the executives worked out the basic design. 1

Seventeen days had passed. Seventeen remained. What made this meeting so different from the first two?

The pattern Connie Gersick found in real teams

Organizational researcher Connie Gersick followed eight project teams from their first meeting to their last. They included graduate students working on management cases, hospital administrators planning a retreat, and the bank executives designing an account. Their projects lasted anywhere from seven days to six months. 1

She wanted to understand how teams developed their work over time. The surprising part was that they did not all move through the same sequence of activities.

Instead, each group established a way of working early on and largely stayed with it through the first half of its schedule. Some teams planned carefully. Others spent weeks exploring possibilities or arguing about what the assignment really required.

Around the midpoint, their approaches changed. Teams reconsidered earlier assumptions, narrowed their options, made new plans, or brought in outside perspectives. The decisions made during that period shaped much of what happened afterward.

Gersick called this pattern punctuated equilibrium: stretches of working within an established approach interrupted by a shorter period of substantial change.

That does not mean the teams were doing nothing before halfway. The bank executives were actively investigating the problem. What changed at their third meeting was the kind of work they were doing. They moved from finding out what needed to be decided to making the decisions themselves.

And the shift was not always productive. In one of the eight teams, a long-running disagreement ended with the leader choosing a plan and disbanding the group. Reaching the midpoint created a turning point, not necessarily a good one.

What happened when teams had only one hour?

Gersick later examined the same idea in a more controlled setting. This time, eight small groups of MBA students had one hour to create a 60-second radio advertisement for an airline. They received background information, a budget, music and sound effects, and instructions about what the client wanted. Their work was videotaped, and afterward the students watched parts of their meetings and described what they had been thinking. 2

The groups began in different ways. Some discussed the airline's message. Others explored possible formats or tried to settle on an idea everyone could use.

As the halfway point approached, several groups changed what they were doing. Rather than continuing to collect ideas, they began choosing what belonged in the advertisement and how to put it together. One group turned to the supplied music tapes when its discussion was going nowhere. Listening to the music helped the members find a direction for the commercial.

In six of the eight groups, the main transition occurred around the 30-minute mark. One shifted earlier and another later. Participants' comments linked these changes to their awareness of the time remaining.

But one group failed to turn its discussion into a finished advertisement. Feeling the deadline approach did not, by itself, solve its problems.

The laboratory study helps explain the original field observations. The important shift was not simply that people started working faster. They began looking at the task differently: closing off some possibilities and choosing a basis for what to do next.

Halfway is not a magic moment

Later studies also complicate the story. In an experiment involving 38 groups, researchers Mary Waller, Mary Zellmer-Bruhn, and Robert Giambatista found that groups changed task activities at or near the midpoint, but their attention to time increased gradually as deadlines approached. There was no sudden jump in time awareness exactly halfway through. 3

So the research does not tell us that every group will change direction at the precise midpoint, or that a countdown automatically improves group decisions.

The studies mainly concern temporary groups doing open-ended work with deadlines and some freedom to change their approach. A short workshop activity is not the same as a months-long project, and an observed pattern is not proof that a facilitator can produce better results by interrupting a group at a fixed minute.

What the research does offer is a useful thing to watch for: a group can stay committed to an early approach even after that approach stops helping. The remaining time may give members a reason to reconsider it.

When the group's method no longer fits the time left

Imagine a team in a workshop with 30 minutes to rank twelve possible responses to a fictional emergency. This is a hypothetical example.

Eighteen minutes in, the team has discussed only four options. For each one, participants have tried to reach full agreement before moving to the next. The conversation is thoughtful, but eight options are still untouched and the group has no complete list.

A facilitator could simply warn everyone that time is running out. The team might then rush through the same item-by-item process. Instead, the facilitator asks:

"You have twelve minutes left and eight options you haven't discussed. Is deciding one item at a time still the best way to finish?"

One participant suggests putting all twelve options into a rough order, then spending the remaining minutes on the placements that seem most uncertain. Another worries this will mean skipping important details. The group decides to try the new approach.

That change does not guarantee a better ranking. Some options may receive less attention than they deserve. But the group has made a deliberate choice about how to use the time it has left, rather than simply continuing its initial routine.

Now imagine another team that already has a complete provisional list and is carefully discussing its two hardest choices. Interrupting that team just because the clock has passed halfway could make the session worse, not better.

The more useful signal is a mismatch between the time remaining and the way a group is working. A facilitator can point out that mismatch without deciding the group's priorities for it. This is a practical suggestion drawn from the research, not an intervention that Gersick tested.

Did the team change its approach, or just speed up?

In timed team exercises such as Protocol15, a countdown shows how much time remains, and the final ranking shows what the group agreed on. Neither tells a facilitator how participants organized their discussion, or whether they changed that approach when time became scarce.

One question can make that difference visible afterward:

"As the deadline got closer, did you change how you worked, or did you just try to work faster?"

Some teams may describe switching from detailed debate to a provisional list. Others may realize they kept using the same method even when there was no longer enough time to finish properly. Those accounts give the facilitator something specific to explore without treating the final ranking as proof of a good or bad process.

The clock tells a group how much time it has left. It cannot tell the group whether its current way of working still makes sense.

Research references

  1. Gersick, C. J. G. (1988). Time and transition in work teams: Toward a new model of group development. Academy of Management Journal, 31(1), 9-41. DOI: 10.5465/256496
  2. Gersick, C. J. G. (1989). Marking time: Predictable transitions in task groups. Academy of Management Journal, 32(2), 274-309. DOI: 10.5465/256363
  3. Waller, M. J., Zellmer-Bruhn, M. E., & Giambatista, R. C. (2002). Watching the clock: Group pacing behavior under dynamic deadlines. Academy of Management Journal, 45(5), 1046-1055. DOI: 10.5465/3069329